Seriously. I don’t know if it’s because it’s the summer but these breadtube kids are popping up everywhere these last few weeks.
And they consistently have ignorant, bad takes to share. They don’t understand anything about everything but think that because they’ve watched some guy yell at his screen for a few hours they’re suddenly
They’re people who don’t want to read theory because it’s boring (I think it requires time but it’s very interesting, just needs some motivation to get started) but they will happily watch 3 hours long debates that turn into random shit halfway through.
I don’t mean to rant but I’ve just had a Destiny stan tell me “holocaust denialism on the left” for not believing the uyghur thing. Destiny despises communists and anarchists, the latter of which that person identifies as. They don’t understand what holocaust denialism even is, they don’t understand how people could come to different conclusions than them, they literally just want to feel superior because they’re pure and we’re not, somehow.
They think this will score them points with libertarians and neolibs (and maybe even fascists, as they don’t even understand fascism), by pushing under the bus the only other people who are tangentially related to them. But the libertarians don’t give a shit. They’ll line up anarchists against the wall all the same. We’re all godless commies to them, it doesn’t matter your specific brand.
When was the last time an anarchist called you a Marxist-Leninist? They just say tankie now, as if it had any useful meaning (everyone has their own definition). It’s clear that they they acquired this word through memetic usage and don’t even know what it means. In some cases, I kid you not, people will say tankie but then ask “What’s ML mean?”.
Breadtube was a mistake, cancel that whole shit and get people back in books. Or at least watching important people, not some random bloke from a big city who started a youtube channel.
^ if it’s not high-effort or serious enough for c/communism please tell me where to repost, I’m not sure where else it can fit. Maybe my own c/comradelyrants lol but it’s dead :(
When was the last time an anarchist called you a Marxist-Leninist? They just say tankie now
Sometimes, they proceed to tell you how they are different terms.
- Nah bro, I’m not talking about MLs, I only talk about tankies.
- What’s the difference?
- proceeds to give a ridiculous definition that isn’t applicable to anyone.Btw, the word tankie is starting to cringe me ngl.
Its even used by monarchists and neo-conservatives now. Thanks anarchists for completely missing the class analysis of why tanks were and continue to be 100% necessary to defend AES.
It’s so absurd. Like, it’s a term that came from these same types mocking supporters of the Soviet intervention in Hungary in 1956. You know, a “”“popular”“” uprising where fascists and capitalists supported by the US took legitimate unrest and tried to use it to spark a color revolution. With Hong Kong and Uyghur genocide, as bullshit and thoroughly debunked as they are even now, at least there’s some element of doubt in that they’re very recent and ongoing? But just look at Hungary now and tell me that shit in 1956 wasn’t completely justified.
And yet they still use that word in the exact same way. Fuckin idealism.
