• grue@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    edit-2
    1 year ago

    Focusing on the number of parking spots is somewhat backwards and hostile to the citizen. The number of spots is the effect of poor urban design, not the cause.

    No, it really is the cause. Having lots of parking spaces physically forces destinations to be further apart, which is what makes people not want to walk between them. Moreover, the reason those parking spaces got built in the first place is because they were forced to be by having large minimum parking requirements in the zoning code, not because property owners necessarily wanted them. (You can tell because traditional development patterns, which are what you get when there’s no zoning code mandating it be done differently, does not tend to feature large amounts of parking – even when it was built in times well into the automobile era (including the present day in places outside North America where it’s still allowed).

    I remember a while back coming across a post about old FHA and/or HUD design guidelines for commercial developments from (I think) 1938. It illustrated perfectly the sort of thing I’m talking about: it literally had side-by-side plan view diagrams with traditional commercial (think “main street” shops with no parking in front, or only on-street parking) labeled “bad” and shopping centers with off-street parking labeled “good.” I wish I could find it again.

    Make no mistake: the suburban experiment wasn’t some kind of “natural march of progress” or whatever. It was the result of deliberate policy choices dictated from the top down by the Federal government.

    • confusedbytheBasics@kbin.social
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      1 year ago

      I love visiting town centers with hardly any parking. The whole downtown feels so walkable. Exploring is fun. It’s what the modern suburban “outdoor malls” are trying to replicate artificially all over the USA but it’s so much better when it’s not controlled b a single property owner.

      • AA5B@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        1 year ago

        Are you sure we’re not talking about the same thing while seemingly saying opposite?

        I love that my town has a “traditional” Main Street and town common. All these great common resources near each other and very walkable. During COViD I started a regular activity with my kids to walk to the common, get takeout from a new Pakistani place, to eat in the Common. Then walk down the street for some Boba or ice cream.

        Cars are not a problem. There is some street parking but not much, or my town has been closing the street to cars on summer weekends. I love it.

        However there is also plenty of parking, just not where it interferes with people . There are small to medium lots behind the stores along the street, there are garages at the train station and movie theater, a lot at City Hall, etc

        I may have a fmdifferent experience than most in the US, where I see both walkability and parking. I see opportunity to travel without car, without making drivers miserable. We don’t have to pick all it nothing