The issue is the power disparity between Canada and the US. In the EU, that power disparity is weakened due to how many countries in the EU and how a few of the countries are somewhat similar in power.
In North America version of the EU, it would be: Canada, the US, maybe Mexico and a handful of Caribbean countries. The US would dominate the economic agenda as no one would equal the power of the US even if everyone joined together. The most likely outcome would be everyone would a “colony” to the US economic interests.
Everyone who has lived in the geographic neighbourhood of the US know quite well how US culture has dominated over native culture.
If it was an EU setup, Canada would still be separate. Germany and France are still separate countries despite being in the EU.
I think a similar North American trade union would not be the worst of ideas, but not with Trump in charge of the U.S. part.
The issue is the power disparity between Canada and the US. In the EU, that power disparity is weakened due to how many countries in the EU and how a few of the countries are somewhat similar in power.
In North America version of the EU, it would be: Canada, the US, maybe Mexico and a handful of Caribbean countries. The US would dominate the economic agenda as no one would equal the power of the US even if everyone joined together. The most likely outcome would be everyone would a “colony” to the US economic interests.
Everyone who has lived in the geographic neighbourhood of the US know quite well how US culture has dominated over native culture.