• tias@discuss.tchncs.de
    12·
    1 day ago

    I mean I understand all of these things. But the question is worded in a way that can be interpreted wildly differently depending on the political affiliation of the person responding.

    • Mistic@lemmy.world
      5·
      1 day ago

      It’s simple math and understanding of the law, what does political affiliation has to do with it?

      0.05$ is not a substantial amount of money regardless of your political views.

      Am I missing some context here that there’s new taxes passed by Trump? (Am not American)

      • tias@discuss.tchncs.de
        21·
        1 day ago

        No, 0.05$ is not a substantial amount of money. A 5 percentage points tax increase could be considered substantial. The question is worded so that it can be interpreted in the latter way, and it’s also using a subjective word like “substantial”. Somebody who is politically against taxes is likely to interpret it the latter way, and hence the poll’s results are skewed by its vagueness.

        If we want to measure math skills and understanding of the law, a better question would be by how many dollars the total tax would increase. This would also give us better information on how far off people are.

        • General_Effort@lemmy.worldOP
          4·
          1 day ago

          This may be a language issue. “Bill” in this context means the total amount you have to pay. EG A restaurant bill is what you get from a waiter when you want to pay.

        • jj4211@lemmy.world
          31·
          1 day ago

          But your tax bill doesn’t go up 5%.

          Ok, let’s get this close to real numbers. The cited tax brackets don’t exist, so I’ll go with the 24% to 32%. So if your earnings are 1 dollar into the 32% tax bracket, you are going from AGI $191,950 to $191,951. Your tax bill at $191,950 would be:

          $11,600 * 0.10 +
$35,550 * 0.12 +
$53,375 * 0.22 +
$91,425 * 0.24 
---------------------------------
$39,110.74

          And your tax bill at $191,951 would be:

          $11,600 * 0.10 +
$35,550 * 0.12 +
$53,375 * 0.22 +
$91,425 * 0.24 +
$1 * 0.32
--------------------------------------
$39,111.06

          Your tax bill goes up by a whopping $0.32 or 0.01% by earning that extra dollar, meaning you still got to keep $0.68 of that dollar. When they say that dollar would cause their tax bill to go up a lot, that’s pretty much exclusively owing to the misconception that people assume their tax bill would have gone to $61,424, so in the misconception that dollar would have cost them $22,313.

          • tias@discuss.tchncs.de
            11·
            19 hours ago

            Please, you’re wasting your time explaining. I know all this. I’m talking about how a libertarian would interpret the question due to its ambiguous phrasing. My only point is that of the original parent comment: the methodology of the researcher is bad.