Yesterday evening I saw an alert on my phone that an NFC device was identified near me. I tap it, and it showed me the serial number of an AirTag (which I didn’t think to screenshot), and the associated phone number for the tag were the last four digits of my phone number. So I tapped identify and it couldn’t find it. Now under find my in the AirTags tab, it shows a link identify found item. I tap it, it searches but can’t find anything. All of my and my wife’s AirTags check out and have checked in recently. I did a hard restart of my phone but the link is still there afterwards.

Any suggestions?