So Season 25 establishes that Tolkien’s name is Tolkien and after that the subtitles on Max from previous episodes accommodate that, which is really cool, but there’s still the episode where Cartman wore a shirt that said “Token’s Life Matters”. Why did he write Token if he was talking about Tolkien?
That’s the whole point of the Tolkien joke.
I thought the point of the Tolkien joke was that everyone knew he was called Tolkien except for Stan, so why did Cartman where a shirt that said “Token’s Life Matters” if he knew his name was Tolkien?