Hol up, where in your quotes did they mention genocide against Israelis? Supporting the end of Palestinian genocide and apartheid isn’t calling for genocide of Israelis.
“From the river to the sea!” is a slogan used by both Israelis and Palestinians in support of ethnonationalist aims at exterminating the other from the Levant.
Someone hasn’t been paying attention to the demands of Palestinian nationalists. Or, for that matter, the bootlicking support of some Western leftists for the ethnic cleansing of the ‘settler’ population of Israel (used explicitly in reference to all of Israel, not the illegal settlements in the West Bank)
Every Palestinian is a nationalist I guess. And good thing I’m not a leftist, I’m Marxist. Leftist is such a vague term as to be meaningless. Get off twitter dipshit.
If your suggestion was “We should ethnically cleanse the US of everyone except pureblooded Native Americans”, yes, I would call you genocidal, the fuck kind of question is that
It absolutely is about genocide, in the mouths of Israelis and Palestinians alike.
Okay, before we continue this discussion - would the ethnic cleansing of every or nearly every Israeli from the territory of modern-day Israel be genocide - yes or no?
It’s only genocide if it’s against members of a race. I have nothing against the Jewish community, but the world would be better off without the nation of Israel
It’s only genocide if it’s against members of a race. I have nothing against the Jewish community, but the world would be better off without the nation of Israel
I wish I was surprised at support for genocide on here. I really wish I was.
Don’t insult your own intelligence by pretending that is a good faith reaction.
Nobody feels like explaining to you for the 10000th time that there is clear difference between someone’s feelings on the nation that is called Israel and its associated government…. and Jewish people. Those are two separate concepts but you know that, you are just trying to waste our breath arguing in circles.
If you think genocide of Israelis is fine just because it’s not genocide of non-Israeli Jews, you’re a genocidal shithead, and I have nothing to say to you.
It’s only genocide if it’s against members of a race.
Is pretty clear.
Second, the demands of One-State Solution Palestinian nationalists since the last breakdown of peace negotiations has been, and was historically, the ethnic cleansing of Israelis from the territory of what is currently Israel.
If you have a magic wand you can wave to remove Israel’s existence from the timeline, feel free to break it out, but otherwise, we’re talking death and mass deportations - you know, what the Israelis are doing to the Palestinians right now.
“Genocide against Palestinians bad. Genocide against Israelis BASED!” - Tankie shitheads
Hol up, where in your quotes did they mention genocide against Israelis? Supporting the end of Palestinian genocide and apartheid isn’t calling for genocide of Israelis.
“From the river to the sea!” is a slogan used by both Israelis and Palestinians in support of ethnonationalist aims at exterminating the other from the Levant.
Liberating Palestine in no way means Israelites gets genocided they simply become Palestinians, dumbass.
Someone hasn’t been paying attention to the demands of Palestinian nationalists. Or, for that matter, the bootlicking support of some Western leftists for the ethnic cleansing of the ‘settler’ population of Israel (used explicitly in reference to all of Israel, not the illegal settlements in the West Bank)
Every Palestinian is a nationalist I guess. And good thing I’m not a leftist, I’m Marxist. Leftist is such a vague term as to be meaningless. Get off twitter dipshit.
… nationalism is currently very popular in Palestine, yes.
“I’m not a dog, I’m a pug!”
Uh-huh.
Don’t have twitter. Never have.
Would you call me genocidal if this was about America and its many crimes of genocide and stealing land?
If your suggestion was “We should ethnically cleanse the US of everyone except pureblooded Native Americans”, yes, I would call you genocidal, the fuck kind of question is that
deleted by creator
You… think I’m a Zionist because I don’t support ethnic cleansing of Israelis or Palestinians?
Sorry that I think genocide is bad in all circumstances?
deleted by creator
It absolutely is about genocide, in the mouths of Israelis and Palestinians alike.
Okay, before we continue this discussion - would the ethnic cleansing of every or nearly every Israeli from the territory of modern-day Israel be genocide - yes or no?
This is true
That tankies say that? Or that genocide is only bad when done on the Wrong People™?
It’s only genocide if it’s against members of a race. I have nothing against the Jewish community, but the world would be better off without the nation of Israel
You’re a fucking moron. It’d be funny if it weren’t dangerous.
I wish I was surprised at support for genocide on here. I really wish I was.
Don’t insult your own intelligence by pretending that is a good faith reaction.
Nobody feels like explaining to you for the 10000th time that there is clear difference between someone’s feelings on the nation that is called Israel and its associated government…. and Jewish people. Those are two separate concepts but you know that, you are just trying to waste our breath arguing in circles.
If you think genocide of Israelis is fine just because it’s not genocide of non-Israeli Jews, you’re a genocidal shithead, and I have nothing to say to you.
Again, where does ending the state of Israel mean you have to kill their citizens?
First,
Is pretty clear.
Second, the demands of One-State Solution Palestinian nationalists since the last breakdown of peace negotiations has been, and was historically, the ethnic cleansing of Israelis from the territory of what is currently Israel.
If you have a magic wand you can wave to remove Israel’s existence from the timeline, feel free to break it out, but otherwise, we’re talking death and mass deportations - you know, what the Israelis are doing to the Palestinians right now.