Good day comrades and welcome to my first Hexbear post.
Like many others here, I have participated with delight in the Western invasion/migration to 小红书. Hearing from the Chinese people directly has truly restored some of my faith in humanity.
Also like many others I am grateful every day for their revolution and steadfast and peaceful development over the decades, especially lately with climate change looming and no other nations rising to the challenge.
Thirdly, after understanding CIA media operations and anticommunist agitprop I now don’t personally object to what we call “censorship” over here. It seems legitimate to me for the dictatorship of the proletariat to manage the “Overton Window”, (lest it be managed instead by capital and its convenient alliance with jingoism).
Now for the hard questions.
I spoke with a Chinese citizen and acquaintance about all this. Aside from their reluctance to discuss politics I was also troubled by their assessment of the labor situation in China.
According to them, there are unions but they are state controlled and useless. They say the work culture is brutal and unsustainable and that doing true organizing will result in imprisonment.
I am coming to this question from a place of wanting to learn from the premier Marxist country and government, but I can’t make it reconcile in my head. I would perhaps ask this question on 小红书 but I don’t think this discourse would be welcome in that community.
Were unions weaponized by foreign powers in China’s past? Is my acquaintance biased/unrepresentative? Is the connection between organized labor and Marxism less ironclad than I always assumed? What do you think comrades?
I don’t have any specifics to add but I do want to point out that you’ve selected one person out of literally over a billion in China. There are reactionaries in China. There is a full spectrum of people with different material conditions, opinions, and perspectives. It’s a really massive place both in a physical and cultural sense, bigger than any one person.
That was one of the options I considered in my post, but I obviously found it too unsatisfying not to write out all that text.
I did a bit more research after your comment and it appears to be true that the only legal labor organizing goes through the state union. I also think I have seen enough evidence to believe that 996 work culture is real and not a Western fabrication. That doesn’t leave me personally with “nothing to see here”.
I want to be wrong! I don’t think we have any better archetypes to look up to