A big part of why I ended up hear in hexbear is because it’s one of the only places where everybody doesn’t lie about your beliefs to just off handedly dismiss your concerns.
Ok, then I won’t lie and will state the truth as bluntly as possible. I personally think the anti-Russia stance of western socialists is chauvinist and incoherent and have argued as much constantly here, with mixed support. As I have explained down below, it’s a western socialist’s revolutionary defeatist duty to oppose their own empire by being a fifth column and critically supporting its enemies. Lenin was quite clear on this, it does not mean passive fence sitting and both-sidesism. It in fact, is much the opposite. It’s active attacks on one’s own imperialist government through organized activity to interfere with NATO war funds, NATO war supplies, NATO war support, etc.
It’s an incoherent position to say “I oppose my nation’s imperialism but I also oppose the enemies of my nation”. You don’t get to say both. We can argue if the invasion in February 2022 was a strategic error or not, but that doesn’t really matter because we are not Russian war strategizers. We are western socialists. Do you understand your place and role? It’s to weaken your empire, and if you can work with its enemies to do so you should.
It’s really interesting how everybody actually in this sub talks about how it’s bad Russia invaded and they’re deffinitly aggressors and denounce them, we just think nazis are bad.
Z. Russia is defending itself and I support their invasion. I think Nazis are bad and need violent action taken against them when they build up concentrated military power. I’m glad someone is finally doing it, despite Putin being a liberal cuck who waited 8 years too long to do it - strung along by EU perfidy.
I’ve definitely come around from ‘war is bad, no one should be at war’ to ‘the elimination of reactionary forces, specifically those who adorn nazi regalia, is paramount to the continuation of humanity’. Is Russia perfect, no; is Russia killing Nazis at a faster rate than the rest of the world, absolutely yes. Do I want every Nazi in the world dead yesterday, yes; who is going to deliver that goal, Russia; who isn’t going to deliver that goal, US and NATO.
I understand where you are coming from but I have a hard time squaring the circle of “US involvement in the middle east only caused further explosion of extremism” and then acting as if Russia invading Ukraine won’t have the same effect with what they claim to be fighting.
The US involvement in the Middle East has led to an increase in extremism. The US military withdrew from Afghanistan and Western media along with the useful idiots were upset we weren’t continuing the war, those same folks are now thrilled we are supplying Ukraine. The extremism is coming from inside the house.
This and extremism in the Middle East (whatever we wanna define that as) is less immediate or tangibly a threat to Americans as fascism in Ukraine is to Russians. That and the US refused to engage with the governments of these countries and instead blocked diplomacy, whereas Russia did attempt the legal path repeatedly but Minsk kept being violated
Again I see what you are saying, I just don’t agree that what Russia is doing actually delivers the goal you are after, based on our own continual examples that it doesn’t work that way.
Ok, then I won’t lie and will state the truth as bluntly as possible. I personally think the anti-Russia stance of western socialists is chauvinist and incoherent and have argued as much constantly here, with mixed support. As I have explained down below, it’s a western socialist’s revolutionary defeatist duty to oppose their own empire by being a fifth column and critically supporting its enemies. Lenin was quite clear on this, it does not mean passive fence sitting and both-sidesism. It in fact, is much the opposite. It’s active attacks on one’s own imperialist government through organized activity to interfere with NATO war funds, NATO war supplies, NATO war support, etc.
It’s an incoherent position to say “I oppose my nation’s imperialism but I also oppose the enemies of my nation”. You don’t get to say both. We can argue if the invasion in February 2022 was a strategic error or not, but that doesn’t really matter because we are not Russian war strategizers. We are western socialists. Do you understand your place and role? It’s to weaken your empire, and if you can work with its enemies to do so you should.
Z. Russia is defending itself and I support their invasion. I think Nazis are bad and need violent action taken against them when they build up concentrated military power. I’m glad someone is finally doing it, despite Putin being a liberal cuck who waited 8 years too long to do it - strung along by EU perfidy.
I’ve definitely come around from ‘war is bad, no one should be at war’ to ‘the elimination of reactionary forces, specifically those who adorn nazi regalia, is paramount to the continuation of humanity’. Is Russia perfect, no; is Russia killing Nazis at a faster rate than the rest of the world, absolutely yes. Do I want every Nazi in the world dead yesterday, yes; who is going to deliver that goal, Russia; who isn’t going to deliver that goal, US and NATO.
I understand where you are coming from but I have a hard time squaring the circle of “US involvement in the middle east only caused further explosion of extremism” and then acting as if Russia invading Ukraine won’t have the same effect with what they claim to be fighting.
The US involvement in the Middle East has led to an increase in extremism. The US military withdrew from Afghanistan and Western media along with the useful idiots were upset we weren’t continuing the war, those same folks are now thrilled we are supplying Ukraine. The extremism is coming from inside the house.
This and extremism in the Middle East (whatever we wanna define that as) is less immediate or tangibly a threat to Americans as fascism in Ukraine is to Russians. That and the US refused to engage with the governments of these countries and instead blocked diplomacy, whereas Russia did attempt the legal path repeatedly but Minsk kept being violated
Again I see what you are saying, I just don’t agree that what Russia is doing actually delivers the goal you are after, based on our own continual examples that it doesn’t work that way.