I have been using a piantor built for me by beekeeb.com, and am enjoying the more agressive stagger than my previous Ergodox. However, my typing experience is being spoiled by how tight the key spacing is. I have large hands, and can span an octave on a full-size piano; the Piantor is downright cramped.
In looking for a possible replacement (the Kyria was my primary option, but I guess splitkb.com has entirely given up on selling pre-builts, and I don’t solder), what should I be looking at for specs to get some wider spacing on the keys? Is it simply “key spacing?”
Most commercial keyboards are fine; my prior was an Ergodox and the spacing was fine. The Piantor supplies that - it might even be a touch too much, but it’s still better than the tepid stagger on the Ergos.
I think the terms you’re looking for are “choc spacing” and “MX spacing”. Choc spacing is what the Piantor uses where the space for each key is 18 x 17 millimeters. MX spacing is 19 x 19 millimeters.
If you want to keep using low-profile switches, there are a handful of boards that either choc or MX switches, and any of those will always use MX spacing. That said, I don’t think there are a lot of pre-built options in this space.
Maybe check out Klor. I think that one is offered as a pre-built by beekeeb and it uses MX switches. It’s got the more aggressive pinky stagger, but it also has some splay which may or may not be your thing. I just finished building one using tecsee “medium” switches and MTNU keycaps, do it’s lower profile, but still not as low as choc.
there are a handful of boards that either choc or MX switches, and any of those will always use MX spacing
Oh, that helps, thanks!
I don’t think there are a lot of pre-built options in this space
Sadly, no-one wants to pre-build. When the robot revolution comes, my weapon will be a soldering iron, because destroying electronics seems to be all I’m able to achieve with one.
Maybe check out Klor
Thanks, I will. Splay might actually help with my cramping issue.
I love how the chocs look, and they feel ok, but even the browns which are supposed to be tactile feel squishy to me, so I may give up on them and try an MX set, so that all might work out.
Thanks for the advice!
I’d try searching with the term pitch, as that is the typical term for an even spacing of an array of things.
It seems like most key spacing is pretty standard but if you used a board with mx switches, like the Corne, you’d have a bit more room.
“Key spacing” is usually the term.
I think Dao Choc BLE, city42, or the various Hillside keyboards would be the closest that you can get pre-built.
I had similar problems with a Cantor build, and I have pretty small hands. I think the problem was not necessarily the key spacing, but the flat key profile that makes it harder to feel the key positions and easier to press two keys at once. MX keys typically have larger gaps between the key tops, which makes orientation easier for me. Interestingly I also have no problem with chiclet keys on my laptop with 3mm gaps between keys.
I was hoping to try LDSA key caps to fix this, but they never came back in stock before I moved on from my Cantor. There are other sculpted key cap options to try. E.g. https://lowprokb.ca/collections/keycaps/products/ddc-choc-pbt-blank-keycaps, https://www.asymplex.xyz/product/cs-chicago-stenographer-profile or https://3dkeycap.com/products/klp-choc-keycap-set-low-profile-ergonomic-sculpted-keycaps.
Interesting. I have the MBK Legends, which look about as sculpted as those CS Chicago ones; both of the others do have quite a different profile. You may be right; if so, I should try the KLPs, because they’re pretty extreme!
I do think splay is part of my issue, in any case - I feel as if I have to force my fingers closer together than they naturally tend toward.
It’s still cheaper than a new KB, and so worth a shot - thank you!
