The MVP is completely redundant because the All-Pro QB1 is always gonna win. That is why the system about it is flawed.

Let the most prestigious Awards be for everyone and the lesser awards be for positions.

Yes, and that is not the same.

There has been 3 instances in over 60 years where it hasn’t been a QB or RB that won the award, and one of those is a kicker in a strike season. Nfl has almost effectively phased out the workhorse RB with all their rule changes towards the passing game for the past 25 years, so it is effectively only QB that can win it now. You can probably find comparable seasons amongst those 65 years.

A lot of this could be redundant, if American sports would just have an award called “player of the year/season” instead.