After being kicked out of the Labour party for his strong stance for justice and human rights over the last forty years - Corbyn massively defeated the Labou...
It was a better outcome that was expected. Labour’s vote share is weak. Keir’s vote share in his own constituency halved. He’s become the least popular opposition leader to ever win by any metric. The lowest turnout in, like, a hundred years despite this nominally being a regime change election shows a lack of belief and enthusiasm for the current system. Greens did historically well. Independents from the left did historically well. Not just the ones that won, but the ones that came strong second. Many of Labour’s seats were won on a knife edge. It was not a resounding victory of the kind Blair won, which imo was the worst case scenario.
Yes, FPTP means none of that technically matters. But also, it does, because many of Labour’s MPs know they’re on thin ice if they want to win again.
The predicted outcome was a license for absolute red tory arrogance. Wes Streeting was gleefully rubbing his hands at the prospect of selling off the NHS, but maybe winning by only 500 votes will make him think more carefully about that. Or maybe it won’t. Maybe he doesn’t care about being re-elected because he’ll have a gravy train waiting at the station when he leaves.
But I still think there’s something worth celebrating, because despite the compliant media, despite the total Conservative collapse, Labour barely got a better share than they did in 2019 and a significantly worse share than they did in 2017. There is an appetite for left politics, it is a spectre that is haunting the UK. It’s not going to be sated by elections and establishment politics, I’m not under any illusion about that. But the poor turnout indicates that nobody else is either, which is significant. The desire is there, the disillusionment with the current system is there, the results show it.
The danger was always that Farage would be the main beneficiary of this failing system, but this election indicates to me that there is absolutely an opening for the left to win people over.
It’s a bit cope, yes, but it’s not meaningless.
For the next 4 years there’s someone on the right side of issues in parliament, whose voice will be heard by many.
And when you consider that seat could’ve been a pro-Israel private healthcare ghoul, Corbyn’s win does mean something.
Corbyn defeating the red Tory candidate is obviously good and makes a difference by giving the public a voice of reason during the rule of an unchecked red Tory regime.
His win is significant by demonstrating that a good candidate from the labour movement with sound politics can win, even when up against the full weight of the red Tory machine.
He will have no power over government though and he is just a single guy. He is also old and can’t be expected to go on for much longer. If his victory is going to be good for anything he needs to use it to build the foundations for something better, like organising an opposition party together with leftists progressive forces all over the country.
I think it’s important to have such a voice in parliament. I think it would be much worse if it was total labour. Corbyn will stand as inspiration for a lot of resistance.
Good things happening is bad
This election was not a good outcome and Corbyn’s win doesn’t affect anything.
It’s satisfying to see, sure, but celebrating it with a title like this is cope.
I also liked seeing Sunak eat shit but a Starmer win means I’m eating shit too.
Labour Party status: not in fact destroyed and still pro-Israel.
Starmer status: very safely in power and unthreatened by Corbyn. Probably with a wicked champagne hangover.
There’s nothing worth celebrating here except some cope.
It was a better outcome that was expected. Labour’s vote share is weak. Keir’s vote share in his own constituency halved. He’s become the least popular opposition leader to ever win by any metric. The lowest turnout in, like, a hundred years despite this nominally being a regime change election shows a lack of belief and enthusiasm for the current system. Greens did historically well. Independents from the left did historically well. Not just the ones that won, but the ones that came strong second. Many of Labour’s seats were won on a knife edge. It was not a resounding victory of the kind Blair won, which imo was the worst case scenario. Yes, FPTP means none of that technically matters. But also, it does, because many of Labour’s MPs know they’re on thin ice if they want to win again.
The predicted outcome was a license for absolute red tory arrogance. Wes Streeting was gleefully rubbing his hands at the prospect of selling off the NHS, but maybe winning by only 500 votes will make him think more carefully about that. Or maybe it won’t. Maybe he doesn’t care about being re-elected because he’ll have a gravy train waiting at the station when he leaves.
But I still think there’s something worth celebrating, because despite the compliant media, despite the total Conservative collapse, Labour barely got a better share than they did in 2019 and a significantly worse share than they did in 2017. There is an appetite for left politics, it is a spectre that is haunting the UK. It’s not going to be sated by elections and establishment politics, I’m not under any illusion about that. But the poor turnout indicates that nobody else is either, which is significant. The desire is there, the disillusionment with the current system is there, the results show it.
The danger was always that Farage would be the main beneficiary of this failing system, but this election indicates to me that there is absolutely an opening for the left to win people over.
It’s a bit cope, yes, but it’s not meaningless. For the next 4 years there’s someone on the right side of issues in parliament, whose voice will be heard by many. And when you consider that seat could’ve been a pro-Israel private healthcare ghoul, Corbyn’s win does mean something.
Corbyn defeating the red Tory candidate is obviously good and makes a difference by giving the public a voice of reason during the rule of an unchecked red Tory regime.
His win is significant by demonstrating that a good candidate from the labour movement with sound politics can win, even when up against the full weight of the red Tory machine.
He will have no power over government though and he is just a single guy. He is also old and can’t be expected to go on for much longer. If his victory is going to be good for anything he needs to use it to build the foundations for something better, like organising an opposition party together with leftists progressive forces all over the country.
Ok it doesn’t mean nothing it only means next to nothing
I think it’s important to have such a voice in parliament. I think it would be much worse if it was total labour. Corbyn will stand as inspiration for a lot of resistance.
How much have you heard Corbyn’s voice in Parliament since 2019? No one listens to backbenchers.
I can’t say really. I’ve heard him a lot but I’m in his target demographic.
ok