• poVoq@lemmy.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    edit-2
    3 years ago

    Apparently you are absolutely fact resistant. But try to do the math at least once: 8 billion people and a fertility rate of 1.8… how long will that take to human extinction? or 1.5 or even 1.1… just calculate it. In each case it will take hundreds of years.

    Sure you can claim it will go even lower then that, but there is literally zero evidence that people will stop having children all together. Z-E-R-O.

    And claiming to know what will happen with the fertility rate in the next thousands of years is just bullshit. It might as well go up again in a few hundred years, who knows…

    • DPUGT@lemmy.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      3 years ago

      Apparently you are absolutely fact resistant.

      Which fact am I resistant to? I’m resistant to your conclusions, which aren’t worthy of being called facts.

      But try to do the math at least once: 8 billion people and a fertility rate of 1.8

      I’ll wait 20 years until it’s 1.3. Or 40 years until it’s 0.3. The rate’s not constant. You get that right? It’s provably not constant. It’s provably not going up, or fluctuating back or forth, but continues to go downward. That’s not so hard to understand.

      Maybe that’s the fact I’m resistant to. Maybe the fact that it’s currently 1.8, and that you imply there it will stay without anything to corroborate the idea. But also that you only imply it, because to assert such a thing sounds so absurd even you can’t possibly say it with a straight face.

      Sure you can claim it will go even lower then that, but there is literally zero evidence that people will stop having children all together. Z-E-R-O.

      There’s plenty of evidence that the downward trend continues to accelerate, as it has for a century. There’s plenty of evidence that children internalize such things as social norms, and not alot to suggest that this isn’t at least the cause, in part, for the downward trend.

      They don’t have to stop having children. It just has to fall below replacement. At that point you are, as a species, effectively dead. It never recovers.

      And claiming to know what will happen with the fertility rate in the next thousands of years is just bullshit.

      I used to say the same thing about climate. But the difference there is that we’re supposed to believe such things about holy climate science, and disbelieve those things which contradict the dogma of our ideologies.

      It might as well go up again in a few hundred years,

      Magically? Like, your ideology already makes some assumptions about why it went down in the first place. And I’m not saying you are wrong… what makes you think those assumptions won’t continue to hold, when all the statistics say that they are doing just that?

      Dead.

      Your arguments are how soon-to-be dead people think. I’m not unhealthy, so what if I’ve put on a few pounds. Sure, it was a heart attack, but just a mild one and with medicine now days. And I’m too old to do the fitness thing anyway, the medications are a better bet. Maybe they’ll invent whizbang medical technology to make me immortal and I’ll vacation on Neptune! Just dead.