Hello, are people here playing MMOs? What’s your favorite one?
My main MMO is Guild Wars 2. I like that since there’s no sub fee I don’t feel pressured to “get my money’s worth” every month, keeps it from feeling like a job. Of course I do buy some cosmetics from the shop on occasion when I’m actively playing to make up for the lack of a fee.
FF14 is my main MMO but my second one is GW2! I’m playing it with my girlfriend, we don’t play often so not having a sub fee is perfect
Yup, and the progression style is perfect for if you don’t play it often. I took a 3 year break from it from about 2019-2022 and my gear was still good and I was still max level. Didn’t need to do much other than catch up with story (because I chose to, not because it was required).
Also my personal favorite! Which class do you play the most, chronomancer Mesmer for me.
Reaper Necro, so much fun! Nigh unkillable in overworld content as long as I’m actively engaging.
My main is a Guardian, but I’ve been playing a lot of Revenant lately as well.
Guild wars 2, just one that I’ve been playing for years
#1 has gotta be Guild Wars 2. The content is engaging and fun, I adore the combat, and the COMMUNITY is the best! Such friendly folks there. It’s definitely the MMO that has held my attention longest, and I recommend it to literally everyone. It’s free to get started, so you can decide if it’s for you without any monetary cost. Then, the price of the game is the cost of the expansions. No subscriptions like other MMOs, or xpaks + subs (looking at you, WoW!).
#2 is WoW. 😅 Been playing it since I was a kid. My whole family plays, actually, which is how I got into MMOs to begin with. It irks me that there’s a substantial sub fee plus the cost of the new xpaks every time. Especially since I got back into it, I was going to hit max level before I picked up Dragonflight but the game actually stopped me from doing so. Couldn’t go the last 10 levels to max until I bought the expansion.
#3 right now has to be Dungeons and Dragons Online. DDO is a lot of fun! I love the “dungeon master” narration of quests and things, I think it’s a great gimmick.
Outside of that, my tier list really falls apart, lol. I have ESO, but I haven’t given it enough time to actually decide if I like it. FF14 seems so much fun, but it’s also a sub fee game and… I only have space in my life for one of those right now. 😅
I really like FFXIV. It’s the only MMO that’s ever hooked me, and I think that has everything to do with the communit (it definitely wasn’t A Realm Reborn, if anyone checks it out be prepared for the first… Thirty or so hours to be kind of a slog?) . FFXIV folk are just the best.
Yeah the community around XIV is just the best. I dip in and out a couple of times a year but if it wasn’t for the community (and the memes) then it would be much less often.
I have a hard time playing anything but World Of Warcraft (when it comes to MMOs). I always gravitate back towards it (usually only for a couple of weeks every few years). No other MMORPG has really clicked for me.
What I can recommend though for anyone whose favourite WoW was Classic (or any of the earlier expansions) is WoW Classic Hardcore mode. It brought me back playing WoW again for much longer than any of the previous expansions managed to.
I like WoW, but I only play on private servers in hardcore like you. What I prefer in a MMO is the story and the levelling, so I didn’t get a lot of fun on the normal WoW but the hardcore mode make it fun, it touch my love of roguelike
Warframe is in my favourite. Be a space ninja doing flips while electrocuting a whole room of enemies before blowing them up with your hand carried cannon. Also fair monetisation and a very friendly community.
I second this. Warframe is fantastic and so well done. It never feels pay to win.
Final Fantasy XIV. I still love it, after all the years.I’ve started back in the PS3 days and still playing with the same character, on PS4 and PC.
I’ve tried some others over the years, but coming back every time to FF14.
This was going to be my suggestion too. So much content and different things to actually do. Very friendly users on most servers.
Yeah it’s my main one too! What job do you prefer?
Tank. I love it to tank in dungeons. I’ve a red mage, a monk and a white mage too, but tanking is my passion.
Lotro - great community, great designs on raid encounters in endgame, where you will die if not everyone plays their role, starting from tier 2. Tier 1 is always designed as a learning experience before moving to tier 2, which makes it great for casuals like myself to get into. Only issue I have is the bloat of leveling, where you now have to go endless hours untill reaching endgame, almost mostly without seeing other players, as those areas are now empty. Feels more like a mediocre Singleplayer game during that time. Otherwise I have started recently on tWoW, lots of people to quest with, which is great 😃
How is the new update? I would love to get into it but I have trouble with how dated it is sometimes.
Honestly, I haven’t yet played it. The newest update introduces just a new quest zone in Gondor to prepare for the next expansion, coming this autumn. Not so much group content in this, so people still play the gundabad and carn dûm group content. With the raid in carb dûm now only being out for like 2 month, and only being introduced to tier 3, this is still the relevant endgame content to play in.
I’d love to get back into FFXIV, but that was the main game me and my partner played for six years. We are separated now and the memories just too hurtful :/
Used to play a ton of MMOs. Ffxiv was probably my favourite. Tons to do though I mostly focussed on trying to do the difficult boss content. Non existent PvP though which is probably the only downside. New world was quite fun, looks like they added a bunch of new stuff there too but it’s probably not a game that will keep you entertained for a long time. I played archeage as well. Had a very modular class system and the combat was very entertaining imo though it became a p2w type of game.
I remember when Archeage was good, good old times
Heard a sequel is in the making. Hope its good
Yeah I also heard about that, with MMOs it always depend what’s company is in charge. A lot of MMOs are made by Tencent or NCSoft, and they are all P2W
I feel like NCSoft was OK back in the day. My main experience with NCSoft was via Aion. I played when it came out and thought it was a great game at the time. And coulda sworn they had a decent reputation back then.
Now, like you said, they’re just another terrible MMO P2W company. I have no desire to touch any of their games.
My main NCSoft experience is with the OG Guild Wars, what an amazing game. They don’t make 'em like they used to… Lol!
They don’t make 'em like they used to
100%!
I do feel the early/mid 2000s was the like the Golden Era of MMOs. Then things kinda went south as the MMO space got oversaturated with WoW clones and F2Ps with P2W & cash shops proliferated. I played and trialed so many MMOs during that time. Chasing the proverbial dragon, but with MMOs!
And now we’re sorta going through a renaissance with MMOs, given the recent more high profile titles that have been released or are coming soon: New World, Lost Ark, T&L, Blue Protocol, etc.
But it remains to be seen if these games measure up. Still an exciting time though.
You might want to check out FFXIV again, when End walker dropped they redid the PvP systems. I mostly just like to run content and hang with my FC, but a lot of people seem to enjoy the new PvP.
Owh thats good to know might give it a go again
ESO. They’re coming out with a massive expansion in a few days so I got back into it. It is rich in Elder Scrolls lore and has a ton of content, and you can play it solo easily if multiplayer isn’t for you. Scratches the Morrowind/Oblivion/Skyrim itch. Also like that it isn’t pay-to-win.
Yeah I tried it 2 or 3 years ago, I find it was okay but didn’t get attached. I will maybe try it again later, I don’t want to only play MMOs even if I love it
Yeah it does take a little getting used to. I’m not super fond of the combat. Using the bow is much less satisfying than in Skyrim and there’s no ridiculous ragdolling of your foes.
But… the characters and story arcs make up for it, along with the sheer variety of environments and the feel of exploration that comes with it. Morrowind alone feels much like Morrowind of yesteryear.
The customization is also really nice, lots of different outfits to try on and endless ways to decorate your house. It makes the social aspects feel much more natural with that level of expression.
The upper character levels do feel a little samey when getting to high champion levels, but unless you’re min/maxing it doesn’t make a huge difference imo.
i played a few casual ones as a kid (AdventureQuest Worlds, Pirates of the Caribbean) but haven’t played in a while and miss it. i’ve got a copy of Phantasy Star Online for the Gamecube and one of these days i’ll figure out how to log into a fanserver, or just play the still-online PSO II like a normal person hahaha
If you are up for some nostalgia, The Legend of Pirates Online is a fan-made revival of Disney’s Pirates Online.
oh wow this is awesome, thank you for the heads up!
Having an actual good, well-balanced pirate focused mmorpg is literally my biggest rpg dream lmao. We can only hope ;_;
The only one I’m semi active in these days is FF14. I used to be into WoW for a long time, and before that EverQuest. I’ve dabbled with Ultima, Dark Age of Camelot, Guild Wars 1/2, SWTOR, ESO and RuneScape (and EQOA and Phantasy Star Online back in the day if those count) but those top 3 are the only ones I got into extensively.
I used to be a big time WoW player. 15 years I managed to squeeze out of it before I got tired of the new style they made. Got a big ol’ Kirin Tor sorcerer tattoo to commemorate it.
Still looking for a new good “wowkiller” mmorpg, but everything nowadays seems to be too bland for my tastes. What’re your favs?
FF14 and GW2. To find something interesting to you, like you said, it really depend of your tastes. What do you prefer in a MMO?
I like taking my time with things. Doing all the niche sub-par activities. Crafting in lotr online was such fun, even though it was tedious as all hell. Having things that aren’t just ‘get to max level’ or ‘grind gear to make bigger numbers’ is essential. As soon as the game becomes an efficiency simulator, I’m out.
Having good explorable lore is hugely important too. A world thats more interesting than skin deep.
For years I’ve been dreaming of a persistent communal base building game, without the chaotic undertones of something like Rust or 7 Days To Die. Working together to gather resources and make something. Thats my jam.
What would be in your dream MMO?
My dream MMO would probably be a mix of Dofus for the combat and the funny ennemies and FF14 for the graphics and the story/lore
I don’t think there will ever be a true “wowkiller” MMO, because what people are looking for in a “wowkiller” isn’t actually achievable. WoW has a nostalgia that none of the other games can possibly recreate because it was many people’s first ever MMO, and it was the first MMO community they experienced, and it was a cultural phenomenon that no other game can possibly create again. No other game can match that, including WoW itself.
To an extent I agree. The wowkiller dream is just that, a dream. When wow Classic came out, I felt it captured the parts of old game design that I have been missing. Of course, its impossible to make a new game like old wow, particularly because the reason the gameplay is so “good” (in my personal opinion) is because its so dumb. Tedium is a key ingredient. Taking ages to do anything, and waiting tick for tick to do auto attack damage? People would lose their minds.
But I don’t think its actually impossible. I still have (some) faith in the video games industry to innovate and find the formula that’d become a new phenomenon. Nothing can be the same as the first time, the rpg cat is out of the mmo bag in that regard, but I do think there is some mix of gameplay, world design, lore construction, and community interaction, that can bring a new game to the same heights as old wow.
Not very “massive” but still falls into the category: Phantasy Star Online 2 New Genesis
How are you enjoying that? Was thinking about it yesterday. Has the content picked up at all? I didn’t play much but I might go back
I play it every day since launch. The release content steadily; they are four regions now. But if you didnt enjoy the content back then, you’ll probably wont enjoy actual and forth coming content, its all into the same line. Like every phantasy star and every mmo.
