For context, this takes place in my world with intelligent, non-anthro animals trying to live in harmony. This is part of the backstory of my main character and why she’s where she is currently.
The Felines had recently underwent a bloody and violent revolution, replacing their monarchist empire that is very pro-predation (Trophist) with a democratic republic that is very anti-predation (Unitist). Shortly afterward, they signed the Interspecies Peace Agreement and committed to banning predation by all Felines forever, to overwhelming support by the Feline public. Signing of the ISPA not only bans predation but also allows other ISPA members to engage in trade, travel, and exchange of knowledge and technology with the Felines, which is a big deal because the Felines are considered the most technologically advanced taxon, being the first taxon in history to surpass even the humans that lived before all of them millions of years ago.
The Unified Territories, which is an alliance of Unitist small and medium sized animals, including the Felines’ former prey like Avians and Rodents and is considered the second most advanced, took the opportunity to call up the Feline government to ask for a favour. Basically, the Unified Territories Ministry of Science called up the Feline Science Institute (both are government research institutions), and asked if they can have Yvonne Dandelionpaw transferred to one of their labs in the UT. Yvonne Dandelionpaw is a domestic cat who played a major role in recent Feline history: She co-developed something called ATDP, a dietary enzyme supplement that allows obligate carnivores like cats to subsist on plant based alternatives (where the “DP” part is named after her); she participated in the Feline revolution fighting for the Unitist side; and perhaps most importantly, she is one of the main scientists working on something called a quantum interface, which is one of the next frontiers of science that the Felines are actively pursuing. They basically wanted her to come over and work with their own scientists that are also trying to develop a quantum interface, and essentially spun it as “hey, let’s work on this together since you’re an ISPA member now!”
The Feline Science Institute felt rather pressured by the Unified Territories, and responded with something along the lines of “We’re just about okay with that, but you need to ask Yvonne directly. We’re not going to force a Feline to relocate and take a job outside Feline territory.” So they call up Yvonne initially refuses, saying “Well, it’s a interesting offer, but I’d rather stay here and work with my own taxon as we rebuild after the war.” But then the Unified Territories spun it in a different way to her, trying to convince her that a cat coming over to work in a UT government lab would be a great diplomatic opportunity for the two governments, and controversially, basically told her that there are researchers in the UT who are the Felines’ former prey, and “wouldn’t you want to be the one to reconcile with them so they realize how nice modern cats are and ditch that old stereotype of cats being pricks?” At which point she finally agreed to the transfer, on the condition that she remains employed by the Feline Science Institute and basically serves as a liason and diplomatic representative in addition to being a researcher, which the FSI was understandably also very adamant about.
She is now working at a lab in the UT capital city, but the decision to have her there is very controversial on both sides. Many Felines accuse the Unified Territories of using their position among ISPA members to basically poach Feline talent, while many UT citizens accuse Yvonne of being a Feline spy, considering that she is a high ranking member of the Feline government who is working in a classified UT lab.
What are your thoughts on this progression? Is it something that can reasonably happen when two governments are first establishing diplomatic ties? Do you think the way they spun it to Yvonne counted as coercion or guilt tripping? Any other opinions you have I would love to hear that as well!
I’d say it depends on what they are willing to give in return? A favor implies that at some point that government would be willing to lend aid or help or return the favor either right away or in the future. I’d say it’s a trade like any other except given your bit about ISPA that would mean it would have to exist within certain constraints so no war tech? But given that it appears to be a way to actually facilitate world peace between members of a “food chain” who otherwise would probably not get along, I would say more likely. I do think it’s something that could happen but flip that on it’s head. How can this tech be used to do damage to the entity whose scientists possess this knowledge? In the wrong hands, what damage could it do?