We’re trying to organize a hackathon, and one of the users has a proof of concept gateway running allowing Red Reader (and other 3rd party apps) to switch to Lemmy with no changes (except for the API url). It’s basically providing a reddit-compatible api for lemmy.
See https://imgur.com/a/IF5HYGz
And also https://www.reddit.com/r/apihackathon/comments/13yvzg2/rapihackathon_lounge/jmxcq0u/
Obviously coded for a different political reason than what I have in mind (to put it mildly), but I found this which might help: https://github.com/rileynull/RedditLemmyImporter
Yes, but apparently private apps & usage is still free (for now). You just can’t create an app id for use by thousands of users. From https://www.redditinc.com/blog/2023apiupdates :
Our Reddit Data API will still be open for reasonable and appropriate use cases and accessible via our Developer Platform, which is designed to help developers improve the core Reddit experience.
Looking at the query I think it only returns a single row per post. So not really duplicate data. It all looks very straight forward and you’d think all the “_id” and “id” columns are indexed.
I asked for an EXPLAIN ANALYZE plan to see what really happens and where the most time is spent.
If it’s indexes we’ll see quickly. It might strangely be in the WHERE clause. Not sure what Hot_rank()'s implementation is. But we’ll find that out too if we can get the plan timings. Without looking at the numbers it’s all just guessing.
And I can’t run them myself since I don’t have access to a busy instance with their amount of production data. It’s the thing about databases - what runs fast in dev, doesn’t always translate to real workloads.
Thanks. I’ve asked in there for some EXPLAIN ANALYZE plans, so we can see which parts are slow and why. I also think running pgbouncer or a similar connection pooler would be a good idea. Running a production public facing service with only 5 db connections is asking for trouble.
No, joins are always faster. If you ultimately need to combine the data for the app, the database will be faster than your code can do it, since that’s what it was built to do.
Let’s get a hackathon going. Maybe it’s possible to have a project which allows these apps to work with lemmy. I created a sub on reddit for it: https://www.reddit.com/r/apihackathon/
But maybe that’s not the right spot - happy for someone to create a similar community here too.
Where are the bottlenecks? Frontend servers or on the db? I have a lot of experience running postgres at scale.
Might as well ask here since it’s relevant, but I’ve been thinking of spinning up a beefy lemmy instance and “mirroring” some of my favourite reddit subs across into custom mirror communities. A kind of archive but which you can browse from any lemmy UI. For example, there are some news and sports threads I enjoy following. Would this be a good or bad idea? Would it needlessly flood the other instances?
But someone made the point that it might be the 5% which are producing 90% of the content leaving. Don’t know if this is true, but there are a lot of 10+ year long redditors being vocal about the API issue.
I really need some stuff to read on my phone while on the toilet. And reddit is saying I might soon not be able to do that in the way I prefer.
Both of those are amazing, but you gotta admit their UIs are vintage open source, and not in a good way. But once you figure out how it works, it’s great.
/u/whupazz is working on a reddit compatible api for lemmy, meaning most 3rd party apps should work with little or no modification. See it working with RedReader already: https://imgur.com/a/IF5HYGz
Follow or help here: https://www.reddit.com/r/apihackathon/comments/13yvzg2/rapihackathon_lounge/jmxcq0u/