A man who told doctors he ate nothing, but 6–9 pounds of butter, cheese and hamburgers every day for eight months ended up at Tampa General Hospital with yellowish lumps of cholesterol developing on parts of his body.
The backstory: According to JAMA Cardiology, a man, who is only identified as being in his 40s, told doctors that he got diet advice from the internet and began following an extreme carnivore diet.
For eight months, he only ate 6–9 pounds of butter, cheese and hamburgers a day. He stopped eating all carbohydrates, such as bread and sugar.
At first, he said he felt great. He lost weight, became more energetic and had more mental clarity.
But after about eight months, he started developing yellow lesions on his eyelids. Over the next month, the yellow lesions appeared on the palms of his hands, the soles of his feet and his elbows.
Doctors diagnosed him with xanthelasma, a rare condition that impacts about 1% of patients with high cholesterol.
Dig deeper: Xanthelasma is yellow raised deposits of cholesterol that appear under the skin because the body cannot process it.
Ni-ce
Metric conversion: 6-9 pounds is about 2.7kg - 4kg
I kind of want to know what the hell his meals look like to get through that much. We probably go through about 300g of butter a week, as a family of 4.
told doctors he got diet advice from the internet
A genius at work, folks
As someone with some chronic health conditions and managing them with diet and exercise… I can tell you that the internet is a much better source of dietary advice than your GP or even a nutritionist in the vast majority of cases.
I mean maybe like 5% of the advice on the internet is really good on amy given subject. If youre extremely discerning and lnow how to validate your findings and sources, then sure, the internet can be a great resource. The problem is when 95+% of the information is bullshit, thats not really validating when people say they ‘saw it on the internet’. If only 5% of an encyclopedia were true or accurate then you’d throw the whole thing out. Not to mention for a huge portion of the population, when they say ‘the internet’ they really mean facebook.
Yeah I agree that the term “the internet” is not really helpful.
If you want to take care of yourself with an active lifestyle and healthful diet then you’ll want to learn as much as you can, and you’ll probably source a lot of your information from “the internet” whether that’s in the form of subreddits or communities, scientific research, blog posts, podcasts, whatever. Obviously whatever you learn will be applied in concert with the advice you receive from your GP, personal trainer, and nutritionist.
Obviously this is not the same as reading a meme on facebook that said eating 4kg of butter every day helped someone lose weight and deciding to consume butter exclusively for 18 months contrary to advice from their GP and nutritionist.
The problem with nutrition advice from GPs is that it’s just not what they do. GPs prescribe treatments. That’s it. It’s like asking a carpenter for advice about painting.
The problem with nutritionists is that while they have a wealth of knowledge about nutrition generally, managing your macros is more about manipulating your personal preferences. That is to say a nutritionist might be knowlegeable but I’ve never found their advice to be very helpful for me personally.
So.
You didn’t want to follow their professional advice and therefore the Internet is better because you can find someone to tell you what you wanted to hear.
Thats a pretty cynical take and not really what I’m saying at all.
I have type 2 diabetes. I’ve never been clinically obese, nor consumed much sugar, I just lost the genetic lottery and have a sub standard pancreas.
GPs just prescribe meds. More and more meds to manage blood glucose levels. It’s not hyperbole to say that kidney failure and dialysis is a likely outcome albeit 10 years in the future.
Nutritionists will always formulate a “modified Mediterranean diet”, it’s really the only diet that most patients have any chance of adhering to. Advising anything else would be a waste of breath.
Instead ive adopted a very restrictive diet that anyone would struggle to adhere to and most people just wouldn’t attempt. Additionally I’ve been able to maintain enough regular exercise to build some muscle mass and lose some weight. I’m 43 now, but stronger than I’ve been in my entire life.
You’re welcome to be a snarky lemmy commenter if that floats your boat, but the people in my life who care about me, and that I care about, universally acknowledge the extraordinary efforts I have invested in not dying.
I have always followed the advice of my GP and my endocrinologist regarding what medications I should take, but as a result of my own efforts I’ve been able to discontinue most of the meds while keeping my pathology numbers in the right range.
Only you can meaningfully improve your health, and you’ll need to investigate your options online. A GP can prescribe medications for you and tell you that you’ve gone down the wrong path ( like eating 4kg of butter) but they can’t help you figure out how to maintain your health.
In summary, following my GPs advice, and not investigating how to improve my health and lifestyle, would have been rich easier option.
How did he eat hamburgers while avoiding bread?
He put the Pattie between two other patties
Kinda like a double down?
Which, in the words of Michael Swaim, is less of a sandwich and more of a wad.
Dude is trying to turn himself into human Foie gras.
My eyes now want to punch my brain in the throat for being forced to read that.
Have my upvote.
If you would like to read the actual case report: https://hackertalks.com/post/6269770
What is super interesting, is this person consumed 30,000 calories per day, and still lost weight. Admittedly they were eating way too much fat. But it’s still interesting
I imagine with such a large amount of fat, most of it was sliding right through him - I’d not want to see the state of his toilet. He’s probably solely responsible for the local fatberg.
The main thing to take away from the case study is really just that Xanthelasma exists and that you can get it with this kind of diet. That’s more or less all the case study was saying
The rest of the case study isn’t really anything to make much note of. The original case report does not quote a caloric figure. It is also relying on the patient stating that they were losing weight vs any actual measurements. If they were to be eating 30,000 kcal/day and losing weight, something has got to be absurdly wrong with their digestive system
this person consumed 30,000 calories per day
I’m not a foodologist, but that seems like more than the usual amount.
Indeed, foodology is a under researched field, but for most people 2,500 is normal. Athletes can spike up to 10,000.
Thank you, foodologist.
Butterfingers!
Tampa General Hospital
Florida Man
Time to revive that community:
https://feddit.org/post/7523941
I AM BUTTERMAN, spread the word!
6-9 lbs of butter per day?! Pretty sure I’d die from lactose intolerance.
I think it’s a collective 6-9 pounds of butter, cheese and hamburger meat, not 6-9 pounds of butter alone. But either way, nuts.
I’m definitely overweight but I’m not sure I eat 6-9 lbs of food on any given day!
Livin’ the dream!
